Thursday, June 4, 2015

Best Editor - Long Form

This one wasn't too bad.  Only two of the Editors submitted anything to the packet, in both cases lists of what they had edited in the year 2014.  I ranked them based on how much I had enjoyed the books they edited.  I recognize that this is a proxy with issues, but it's what I have.
Sheila Gilbert & Anne Sowards (not necessarily in that order)

Two of the remaining editors work at Baen, edit a variety of works, some I like, some I don't.  They got ranked in a order that seemed appropriate to me:
Jim Minz & Toni Weisskopf

The other nominee was not ranked as I have yet to be able to finish anything he's edited.

No comments:

Post a Comment